Call Now Open 24/17

Call Now Open 24/7

Free Consultation

Get started today

Schedule Your Free Consultation Today!

Fill out the form and someone from our team will contact you. 

    personal injury lawyers in chicago

    Larry Wins! Disparti Law Prevails At The Illinois Supreme Court  

    OVER $1 BILLION IN RECOVERIES FOR OUR CLIENTS

     

    Disparti Law Group prevails! On October 22, 2020, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled in favor of six Plaintiffs in a monumental and law-changing decision challenging the validity of the composition of the Cook County Sheriff’s Merit Board, a Cook County agency charged with overseeing terminations of Cook County Sheriff’s Officers.

     

    The problem alleged by the Plaintiffs was that the Board was not legally-composed according to the Cook County Sheriff’s Merit Board Act, including by lacking appropriate term lengths, balancing of political affiliation of its members, and staggering of terms. Such requirements were in place to ensure that the Board maintained a balance of experience and political affiliation among its members that would help ensure fairness in its decisions and due process for officers facing hearings before it. Of particular note was that the Cook County Circuit Court and the Illinois Appellate Court had already ruled that the Board was invalidly-composed in 2014, and, again, twice in 2016. The Plaintiffs alleged that the Sheriff was still not following the statute or those Court orders, and sued for injunctive and declaratory relief, seeking to stop their cases from being heard by an illegal Board.

     

    The Circuit Court dismissed Plaintiffs’ case in July 2018, reasoning that they had to raise the issue at the Board, let their proceedings run to completion, and then sue over the validity of the Board. On appeal, the First District Appellate Court of Illinois disagreed, finding that the Plaintiffs did not have to raise the issue at the Board before suing, and further finding that Plaintiffs did raise it sat the Board, but the Board declined to hear the issue. More importantly, the First District Appellate Court ruled that a little-known legal rule called the “de facto officer doctrine,” which can hold that decisions from agencies with defects are treated as if they are legally valid, did not apply because the Sheriff and the Board were already on notice of the issue from the 2014 and 2016 Court orders, but continued operating with defects anyway. The Sheriff filed an appeal to the Illinois Supreme Court, which granted leave to appeal on September 25, 2019.

     

    Faced with briefs by the Sheriff, Cook County, and the Board, and by the State of Illinois and the City of Chicago as amici curiae, these six Plaintiffs faced a David-and-Goliath fight against the three biggest governments in the State before its highest Court. In a sweeping decision, however, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled in favor of Plaintiffs’ right to challenge agency defects on every front, and to seek back pay for periods they were wrongfully-suspended by the Sheriff pending a hearing before a Board that they alleged was invalidly-composed.

     

    “This Decision is so important because it sends a message to government officials that they have to follow the law, and that they have to follow Court orders,” said Disparti Law Group Owner and Founder, Larry Disparti.  Attorney Cass Casper, one of the attorneys who handled the case, added, “This whole situation could have been prevented if Cook County government officials had simply done what the law and the Courts said they have to do.  The real win here is for government accountability and respect for the rule of law.”

     

    The case has been remanded to the Circuit Court of Cook County for further proceedings, including potential class certification for all officers impacted by the decision and back pay.

     

    The Disparti Law Group focuses on the key employment laws: discrimination, minimum wage, workplace safety & health laws, and workers’ compensation.  We provide the highest quality representation for individuals in disputes against employers of all sizes, from small local businesses to the largest corporations. When it comes to employment law, Larry Wins

     

     

    Read More

    Follow Us

    #LARRYWINS

    workers compensation attorneys in dc

    The Disparti Law Group is one of the most successful law firms serving the greater Chicago and Tampa areas. As the leader in Injury, Disability, Workers’ Comp, and Employment Law, with more than $1 Billion in recoveries, The Disparti Law Group has been named One of the Most Influential Law Firms in America by Trial Lawyer Magazine.

    Practice Areas

    FREE CASE CONSULTATION

      Recent Posts

      CLIENT REVIEWS

      Was a great fit for me and would definitely recommend to family and friends!

       – Christine

      It has been a wonderful experience working with Disparti Law Group. They are highly recommended.

      John

      I feel you guys did a great job in handling my case.

      V. Gentry

      Very professional staff, great experience.

      Lisa

      Why Choose Us

      CONTACT LARRY

      FREE CASE EVALUATION

      YOU WON'T PAY A PENNY UNTIL LARRY WINS

        TAMPA

        1041 U.S. Highway 19
        Holiday, FL 34691
        727-600-6000

        CHICAGO

        121 W Wacker Drive, Suite 2300
        Chicago, IL 60601
        312-600-6000